Can't Stop Won't Stop is an excellent "History of the Hip-Hop Generation," even if it wasn't exactly what I was hoping for.
I knew this book by its reputation as the definitive book about the birth and global takeover of hip-hop. I knew, too, that it addresses the social and cultural context from which hip-hop sprang. What I didn't know was that it covers the sociology of hip-hop without much focus on its artistic development. Chang talks about changes in the music — such as the shift from the early focus on the DJ to the ascendance of the MC — only when the development supports his point about cultural changes.
So I learned less about the artistic evolution of hip-hop than I wanted. On the other hand, I got a very strong portrait of the social milieu of young people of color in the 1980s and 1990s. Chang is clearly not unbiased; he writes from the young people's point of view in a style that borders on self-congratulatory. For example, he describes the attitudes of young gang members about the police without exploring the other side. This approach makes the book practically a manifesto for the hip-hop generation, not just a history of it.
I knew this book by its reputation as the definitive book about the birth and global takeover of hip-hop. I knew, too, that it addresses the social and cultural context from which hip-hop sprang. What I didn't know was that it covers the sociology of hip-hop without much focus on its artistic development. Chang talks about changes in the music — such as the shift from the early focus on the DJ to the ascendance of the MC — only when the development supports his point about cultural changes.
So I learned less about the artistic evolution of hip-hop than I wanted. On the other hand, I got a very strong portrait of the social milieu of young people of color in the 1980s and 1990s. Chang is clearly not unbiased; he writes from the young people's point of view in a style that borders on self-congratulatory. For example, he describes the attitudes of young gang members about the police without exploring the other side. This approach makes the book practically a manifesto for the hip-hop generation, not just a history of it.
No comments:
Post a Comment