I went through an Alistair Maclean phase in high school, or possibly junior high school, and I remember Ice Station Zebra being my favorite. So I picked up a copy to read again to see whether it holds up after all these years. And it mostly does.
It shares a lot of the vices of popular action fiction: two-dimensional characters who are always the best in the world, embarrassing "clever" dialogue between them, and an Agatha Christie-style climax with the detective explaining the solution in the drawing room (in this case, the wardroom of a nuclear submarine). However, the action itself really engaged me, especially in the first half of the book.
The story involves a nuclear submarine traveling under the polar ice pack, trying to locate and rescue the meteorological research station Drift Ice Station Zebra. The logistics of the submarine, the navigational challenges, and the polar environment interested me enough that I forgave the expository dialogue. The tension felt well earned. The second half of the book, after they (spoiler alert!) locate the ice station, is still well executed but becomes more like a typical murder mystery. I enjoyed this section the most when it shifted its attention away from the mystery and back to a complication on the submarine.
It shares a lot of the vices of popular action fiction: two-dimensional characters who are always the best in the world, embarrassing "clever" dialogue between them, and an Agatha Christie-style climax with the detective explaining the solution in the drawing room (in this case, the wardroom of a nuclear submarine). However, the action itself really engaged me, especially in the first half of the book.
The story involves a nuclear submarine traveling under the polar ice pack, trying to locate and rescue the meteorological research station Drift Ice Station Zebra. The logistics of the submarine, the navigational challenges, and the polar environment interested me enough that I forgave the expository dialogue. The tension felt well earned. The second half of the book, after they (spoiler alert!) locate the ice station, is still well executed but becomes more like a typical murder mystery. I enjoyed this section the most when it shifted its attention away from the mystery and back to a complication on the submarine.
No comments:
Post a Comment